Pilates vs Weight Training - which one is best?
March 4, 2025
Pilates vs Weight Training - which one is best?
Strength training is a mainstay of a healthy lifestyle, but the approach you choose—Pilates or weight training—can influence the outcomes you achieve. At EBR Physio, many clients ask about which approach suits their goals. Both methods build strength but differ in execution and benefits. Understanding these distinctions, supported by global research and trends, can guide you in making an informed decision.
1. Resistance Used
- Pilates: Employs body weight, resistance bands, or spring-loaded equipment like the reformer to create controlled resistance. The emphasis is on smooth, deliberate movements targeting multiple muscle groups simultaneously, enhancing control and stability. This approach is beneficial for those recovering from injuries or seeking to build endurance without excessive strain.
- Weight Training: Utilizes external weights such as dumbbells, barbells, or kettlebells to progressively overload muscles. This method leads to increased muscle mass and strength over time, often appealing to athletes or individuals aiming for muscle growth and power. Weight training also contributes to improved bone density, which is particularly important for older adults.
2. Core & Stability Focus
- Pilates: Centers on core activation. Each movement engages the deep stabilizing muscles of the core, improving posture, spinal alignment, and overall balance. This focus makes Pilates especially beneficial for individuals experiencing back pain, postural issues, or those recovering from surgery. read more
- Weight Training: Weight training exercises like squats and deadlifts engage the core but mainly target larger muscles. Core engagement tends to be secondary unless specific exercises targeting the core are incorporated. For clients requiring targeted postural work or core stability, Pilates may offer more direct benefits.
3. Flexibility & Mobility
- Pilates: Places a strong emphasis on mobility and flexibility while strengthening muscles. The controlled nature of Pilates exercises allows joints to move through their full range of motion, reducing stiffness and enhancing overall mobility. This is particularly advantageous for clients with conditions like arthritis, general stiffness, or those returning to movement after an injury.
- Weight Training: Builds muscle strength but can reduce flexibility if not balanced with stretching. Exercises performed with a limited range of motion or improper form may lead to stiffness. Incorporating mobility exercises or integrating Pilates into a weight training regimen can help maintain flexibility.
4. Injury Prevention & Rehabilitation
- Pilates: As a low-impact exercise form, Pilates is excellent for injury prevention and rehabilitation. The focus on controlled movement, posture, and muscle activation makes it ideal for clients recovering from musculoskeletal injuries, surgeries, or chronic pain conditions. At EBR Physio, we often prescribe clinical Pilates programs to support recovery from lower back pain, joint issues, or post-operative rehabilitation.
- Weight Training: When performed correctly, weight training strengthens muscles, bones, and connective tissues, reducing the risk of future injuries. However, poor technique, excessive load, or lack of supervision can lead to injuries, particularly in the lower back, shoulders, and knees. Clients new to resistance training may benefit from combining weight training and Pilates to build strength while maintaining control and minimizing injury risk.
Who May Benefit from Pilates?
Pilates is particularly suited for:
- Individuals recovering from injuries or surgery.
- Those suffering from chronic pain conditions such as lower back pain.
- Clients aiming to improve flexibility, posture, and overall mobility.
- Pregnant or postnatal women seeking a safe method to strengthen their core and pelvic floor.
- Athletes requiring cross-training to enhance stability and control.
- Older adults needing low-impact strength training to prevent falls and maintain mobility.
Who May Benefit from Weight Training?
Weight training is ideal for:
- Individuals looking to build muscle mass and increase strength.
- Those aiming to improve bone density and prevent osteoporosis.
- Athletes requiring explosive power and endurance.
- Clients focused on fat loss and body composition changes.
- Individuals managing metabolic conditions such as diabetes, as weight training improves insulin sensitivity.
Which One is Best for You?
The optimal approach depends on your individual goals, fitness level, and any existing injuries or conditions. Many clients at EBR Physio find that incorporating both Pilates and weight training into their routines provides a balanced, effective way to improve strength, stability, and overall health.
If you're uncertain which option suits you best, our team at EBR Physio can help. We assess your needs and guide you toward the most appropriate strength-training approach for your body.
Building confidence before and after injury or surgery When you’re facing surgery or recovering from an injury, it often feels like your body has let you down. You might worry about whether you’ll get back to normal, whether movement will hurt, or whether you’re doing the “right” things. It’s completely normal to feel unsure, frustrated, or even a bit scared, especially when everyday activities suddenly feel harder than they used to. Before and after surgery, confidence can take a real hit. Pain, stiffness, and uncertainty can make you second-guess every step. You are absolutely not alone in feeling this way. Confidence isn’t just a mindset, it’s a key part of recovery, and it can be rebuilt with the right guidance and support. Why confidence matters Understanding the psychology of confidence Confidence isn’t about pretending everything is fine or pushing through pain. It’s about knowing what your body is capable of, understanding what’s normal, and recognising your progress - even when it feels slow. Recovery isn’t just physical, confidence, education and reassurance are are all key parts of progress. When you understand the “why” behind each exercise and what sensations to expect, fear is replaced with clarity. And clarity builds confidence. Consistency leads to results People who feel safe and informed tend to stay consistent with their rehab. That consistency is what builds long-term strength, mobility, and trust in how your body moves. Preparing before surgery How prehab builds confidence Feeling nervous before surgery is perfectly understandable. Prehabilitation (prehab) helps you feel prepared rather than overwhelmed. You build strength, improve mobility, and learn the exercises you’ll use afterwards so nothing feels foreign once you’re home. VicGov’s Better Health Channel explains the benefits of preparing physically and mentally before surgery: https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/servicesandsupport/seeing-an-allied-health-professional What a typical prehab plan looks like A personalised prehab program often includes: • Gentle strength work (e.g. quads, glutes, core for lower-limb surgeries; shoulder and scapular stabilisers before rotator cuff repair) • Mobility exercises to improve joint movement • Low-impact conditioning for overall fitness • Education about what to expect in hospital and immediately afterwards. • Learning early post-op exercises ahead of time • Strategies for reducing swelling, pain and inflammation Walking into surgery feeling prepared boosts both physical and mental confidence. Rebuilding trust after surgery The early stages of recovery Once surgery is over, recovery really begins. Pain, swelling, or stiffness can make you doubt your body, even when everything is progressing exactly as expected. Gentle, guided movement is what helps tissues heal, restore function, and rebuild trust. The Australian Physiotherapy Association recommends early, guided movement after many procedures to support safe healing: https://australian.physio/ What a typical rehab plan looks like Rehab is structured in stages and matched to your surgeon’s protocol. Early phase (Week 1–3) • Swelling and pain management • Gentle range-of-motion exercises • Supported walking or gait retraining for lower limb or simple arm exercises for shoulders • Safe activation of key muscle groups • Clear guidance on what and how to avoid Middle phase (Week 4–8) • Progressive strengthening • Balance and stability work • Gradual increases in load • Functional tasks such as stairs, sit-to-stand and controlled bending Later phase (Week 8+) • Higher-level strengthening • Functional or sport-specific activities • Hydrotherapy or Clinical Pilates for controlled, confidence-building movement • Planning for long-term independence Each phase is explained clearly so you always know what’s safe, what’s normal, and what comes next. From recovery to resilience Why rehab doesn’t stop when pain settles Pain relief doesn’t mean your recovery is complete. Long-term confidence comes from restoring strength, balance and control. Many people continue with guided exercise, Clinical Pilates or maintenance physio as part of their ongoing wellbeing. The bigger picture • Prehab prepares joints, muscles and the nervous system • Rehab guides how well and how safely you heal • Lifestyle choices; sleep, nutrition, daily movement all support long-term recovery Confidence develops when your recovery has structure, clarity and consistent support. Explore our ongoing exercise and Pilates options . Where EBR fits in Continuing your care after specialist treatment Once your surgeon or specialist completes their part of your treatment, physiotherapy becomes the next essential step. Our physiotherapists work closely with specialists across Melbourne to ensure your rehab aligns with your medical plan. Feeling supported makes it easier to rebuild confidence. Our goal is to guide you from uncertainty to strength, from hesitation to trust, and from recovery to long-term independence. Key takeaways • Confidence is a major factor in surgical and injury recovery. • Prehab helps you feel physically and mentally prepared for surgery. • Early, guided rehab restores trust in your movement. • Progress is gradual but powerful when you have structure and support. • Long-term resilience comes from ongoing strength, stability and good movement habits. • You don’t have to navigate any of this alone. FAQs Do I need to feel confident before surgery? Not at all. Prehab helps build confidence by preparing your body and teaching you what to expect. Is it normal to feel scared to move after surgery? Yes. Pain and stiffness can make you hesitate, even when everything is healing well. How soon will I trust my body again? Many people feel more confident within a few weeks as movement becomes easier and strength starts to return. Can I do the exercises on my own? You can, but physio guidance ensures you’re progressing safely and avoiding compensation or delays. Do I need physio even if the pain has gone? Often yes. Pain relief doesn’t always mean your strength, balance or stability have fully returned. Call to action If you’re preparing for surgery, recovering from an injury, or feeling unsure about how to trust your body again, we’re here to help. Book an appointment online Have questions? Contact our team You can read more about how we support patients preparing for surgery here: https://www.ebrphysio.com.au/our-services
Knee pain help for all ages. Personalised physio, prehab and rehab to avoid surgery and pain meds. Book a consult at EBR Physio Bentleigh East.
Staying active and avoiding injury in your 40s
